Medical Bills After an Accident: The Who, What, When, and How

After a crash or injury, one of the biggest concerns is often how medical bills will be handled. Understanding who pays, what gets paid, when bills should be filed, and how to manage disputes can reduce stress and protect your financial recovery.

This guide breaks down the key steps and considerations for handling medical bills after a personal injury.

Who Is Responsible for Medical Bills?

1. Your Health Insurance

In most cases, health insurance pays medical providers first. This includes:

• Emergency room treatment
• Doctor visits
• Specialist care
• Physical therapy

Health insurance typically covers treatment regardless of fault. After treatment, your provider will bill your insurer just as they would for any health claim.

2. PIP or MedPay Insurance

Depending on where the crash occurred and your policy:

• PIP (Personal Injury Protection) — required in Kentucky, pays medical costs regardless of fault up to policy limits.
• MedPay (Medical Payments Coverage) — optional in Tennessee and elsewhere; similar to PIP in that it pays for treatment regardless of fault.

Both PIP and MedPay are separate from health insurance and can help cover deductibles, copays, and care limitations.

3. At-Fault Driver’s Liability Insurance

If another person’s negligence caused your injury:

• Their liability insurance is responsible for your full injury-related bills as part of your overall claim.
• This includes medical expenses that health insurance or PIP/MedPay doesn’t cover.

However, liability insurance typically pays after fault is determined and after other coverages are applied.

4. Your Own Auto Collision or Injury Coverage

If the at-fault driver has no insurance or insufficient coverage:

• Your uninsured (UM) or underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage can help pay medical costs.
• These policies step in after your health insurance and PIP/MedPay, up to the limits you purchased.

What Bills Should Be Paid?

Medical bills can include:

• Emergency transport (ambulance or air ambulance)
• Hospital treatment and overnight stays
• Diagnostic imaging (X-rays, MRI, CT scans)
• Surgeries and rehabilitation
• Physical therapy and chiropractic care
• Prescription medications
• Durable medical equipment (braces, supports, mobility devices)

All treatment that is reasonably related to the injury should be considered part of your claim.

When Should Medical Bills Be Submitted?

Timeliness is key:

• Submit bills to health insurance immediately after each treatment.
• Submit PIP or MedPay claims promptly. Many policies require billing within a specific time window.
• Include unpaid bills in your personal injury claim once your attorney has established fault or liability.

Delays in submission or documentation can lead to denials or reduced payments, so keep detailed records and follow up quickly.

How Are Medical Bills Paid?

Medical expenses can be covered through a combination of sources:

1. Health insurance pays first
   Your health insurer pays according to your policy terms.
2. PIP or MedPay pays next
   These coverages help fill gaps left by health insurance.
3. At-fault liability insurance pays last
   Once fault is established, the at-fault insurer is responsible for any remaining medical costs, including those not covered by other policies.
4. UM/UIM steps in if needed
   If the at-fault driver’s insurance is unavailable or too low, your own UM/UIM coverage may be triggered to cover the rest.

What to Do If Bills Are Denied or Disputed

Medical billing disputes are common after accidents. Here’s how to handle them:

Check for Errors

• Verify that the bill reflects the correct dates and services.
• Confirm that the billing codes match the treatment received.

Coordinate Coverage

If a bill is denied:

• Appeal to your health insurer if it is a health plan issue.
• Ask that PIP or MedPay be applied where applicable.
• Provide documentation showing the treatment is connected to the injury.

Keep Records

Maintain copies of:

• All bills and statements
• Explanation of Benefits (EOBs)
• Appeal correspondence
• Doctor notes linking treatment to your injuries

Proper documentation helps support appeals and negotiations.

How These Bills Affect Your Injury Claim

Medical bills are not just expenses — they are evidence of injury severity and an important part of your overall damages. In personal injury cases, the total cost of care — past, present, and future — can influence:

• Settlement value
• Negotiation strategy
• Proof of pain and suffering
• Future care needs

Unpaid medical bills may also affect your finances and credit, so addressing them early with the correct insurance coordination is crucial.

Final Thoughts

Medical bills after an injury can be complex, involving multiple layers of coverage. The key points are:

• Know who pays first (health insurance, PIP/MedPay, liability insurance).
• Submit bills promptly to avoid denials.
• Document everything thoroughly.
• Appeal disputes with supporting evidence.

Taking these steps helps ensure that your medical care is paid for and properly valued in any injury claim.

‍