What is a Personal Injury or Wrongful Death Trial Like?

What is a Personal Injury or Wrongful Death Trial Like?

In a personal injury or wrongful death case, a trial presents evidence that tells a story about:
‍

• who was at fault and what negligent conduct occurred
• what losses where caused by the negligent conduct
• who was harmed and how has this harm affected a human being
• what fair and reasonable compensation should the jury award
  ‍

A judge, trained in the law, oversees the trial to ensure both sides have a fair and equal opportunity to present evidence. The strength of the evidence—and how effectively it is presented—depends on the experience and skill of the attorneys representing each party. In a civil case, the Plaintiff is the person bringing the lawsuit, and the Defendant is the party being sued.

Most personal injury or wrongful death trials in Kentucky and Tennessee last two to three days when only two parties are involved. Trials with multiple defendants, numerous witnesses, or complex expert testimony may take significantly longer. Expert testimony, in particular, can require additional time because it must be carefully explained to the jury.

While every case is unique, the trial process generally follows these steps:

1. Opening Statements
   The Plaintiff’s attorney presents the first opening statement. The Defendant may provide an opening statement immediately afterward, or wait until the Plaintiff finishes presenting all evidence.
2. Plaintiff’s Proof
   The Plaintiff presents evidence, including witness testimony, expert analysis, photographs, medical records, and other documentation supporting the claim.
3. Defendant’s Proof
   The Defendant has the opportunity to present evidence and witnesses in response.
4. Motions and Jury Instructions
   Once all evidence is presented, the judge resolves any final motions and then instructs the jury on the applicable law before deliberations begin.
5. Closing Arguments
   The Defendant gives the first closing argument, followed by the Plaintiff’s closing argument.
6. Jury Deliberation and Verdict
   The jury then moves to the deliberation room to review the evidence and reach a verdict. Once a decision is made, the jury returns to the courtroom and the verdict is announced publicly.

Most trials begin around 8:30 a.m. and end around 5:00 p.m., though judges may adjust the schedule as needed based on the pace of testimony and the complexity of the case.

‍